Suburb Comparison · Government Data

Maitland NSW vs Menangle Park NSW: Property Investment Comparison

NSW · 2320  |  NSW · 2563

Maitland, NSW
74
Strong
out of 100
VS
Menangle Park, NSW
61
Good
out of 100

Maitland vs Menangle Park — Head-to-Head Comparison

Metric Maitland Menangle Park Winner
Median Sale Price $660,000 $720,000 Menangle Park ✓
Median Weekly Rent (ABS est.) $610/wk $715/wk Menangle Park ✓
Gross Rental Yield 4.8% 5.2% Menangle Park ✓
1yr Price Growth — — —
5yr Price Growth — — —
👥 Population 1,972 224 Maitland ✓
💵 Median HH Income $64,532/yr $87,724/yr Menangle Park ✓
Renter % 60% 60% Menangle Park ✓
Investment Score 74 61 Maitland ✓

Maitland — Score Breakdown

Yield 14/25
Growth 20/20
Renter Demand 16/15
Affordability 8/15
Income Stability 4/10
Liquidity 7/10
Confidence 5/5

Menangle Park — Score Breakdown

Yield 19/25
Growth 2/20
Renter Demand 15/15
Affordability 8/15
Income Stability 4/10
Liquidity 10/10
Confidence 5/5
📋 Maitland Demographics (ABS 2021)
Population
1,972
Median Income
$64,532/yr
Median Age
43
Renter %
60%
Dwellings
560
📋 Menangle Park Demographics (ABS 2021)
Population
224
Median Income
$87,724/yr
Median Age
39
Renter %
60%
Dwellings
55
Maitland Recent Sales
111 Regent St, Maitland NSW 2320 $435,000
2026-06-10
Ballard St, Maitland NSW 2320 $600,000
2026-06-03
10 Johnson St, Maitland NSW 2320 $420,000
2026-06-02
18 Rose St, Maitland NSW 2320 $825,000
2026-06-02
36 Bonar St, Maitland NSW 2320 $735,000
2026-05-22
Menangle Park Recent Sales
28 Biscay Cct, Menangle Park NSW 2563 $695,000
2026-06-09
2 Beautide St, Menangle Park NSW 2563 $745,000
2026-06-05
11 Rainbird St, Menangle Park NSW 2563 $1,200,000
2026-06-01
56 Danehill Ave, Menangle Park NSW 2563 $670,000
2026-05-29
6 Crisp St, Menangle Park NSW 2563 $1,305,000
2026-05-28
Based on government data
Maitland scores higher for investment potential
With an investment score of 74/100 and 4.8% gross yield, Maitland ranks ahead on our composite scorecard covering yield, affordability, renter demand, income stability, and liquidity.

Not financial advice. Always do your own due diligence.

Maitland full profile → Menangle Park full profile →
Compare a different pair
POPULAR COMPARISONS
Frankston VIC vs Thurgoona NSW Parramatta NSW vs Blacktown NSW Orange NSW vs Bathurst NSW Geelong VIC vs Ballarat VIC Gosford NSW vs Newcastle NSW Mosman NSW vs Manly NSW Chisholm NSW vs Lochinvar NSW

Maitland vs Menangle Park — Frequently Asked Questions

Is Maitland or Menangle Park better for property investment?
On our composite scorecard, Maitland scores 74/100 and Menangle Park scores 61/100, weighing yield, growth, renter demand, affordability, income stability and data confidence. Treat this as a shortlist signal and verify independently.
Which has a higher rental yield, Maitland or Menangle Park?
Maitland shows an indicative gross yield of 4.81% versus 5.16% for Menangle Park, based on public price and rent data.
What is the median house price in Maitland vs Menangle Park?
The median sale price is approximately $660,000 in Maitland and $720,000 in Menangle Park from government public records.
Compare up to 5 suburbs — unlock Pro

Pro also includes Buy Box builder, suburb alerts, deal workbook, and monthly market reports.

Upgrade — $19/month →